In early March Cornerstone Research issued its annual report on stockholder M&A litigation. The report concluded that stockholder litigation challenging public company transactions remains pervasive, with lawsuits filed in connection with 94% of transactions announced in 2013 that were valued at over $100 million. The report also showed that multi-forum M&A litigation remains common, as 62% of stockholder challenges involved actions filed in multiple jurisdictions. However, the report detailed a substantial decrease in the number of cases filed in three jurisdictions, noting a decrease of approximately 50% in such cases over the past three years. This could be attributable to defendants' tactical responses – including the invocation of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act discovery stay – to what had been a rising trend of stockholder plaintiffs filing parallel M&A actions in federal courts.
The report also concluded that – as practitioners are well aware – over 90% of stockholder M&A suits resolve pre-closing through non-monetary settlements. Only 2% of settlements reached in 2013 involved a monetary payment, as the vast majority of settlements included only the issuance of supplemental public disclosures and/or a modification of deal terms. The plaintiffs' attorneys' fees associated with such non-monetary settlements declined in 2013, with the average fee requested declining to $1.1 million in 2013 from $1.4 million in 2011 and 2012. Fee awards similarly declined, with plaintiffs receiving average awards of less than $500,000. The Delaware Court of Chancery also appears to have been more active in reducing requested plaintiffs' fee awards, awarding less than the requested fees in almost 35% of settlements.(1)
For further information on this topic please contact Martin J Crisp or Carl Marcellino at Ropes & Gray LLP by telephone (+1 212 596 9000), fax (+1 212 596 9090) or email (firstname.lastname@example.org or email@example.com). The Ropes & Gray LLP website can be accessed atwww.ropesgray.com.