Kim Kardashian filed a lawsuit in the United States District Court for the Central District of California against Old Navy for using a model/actress that allegedly looks like her and calls her to mind in its commercials. Some speculate that the reason Kim filed the suit was to protect her apparel licensing deal with Sears because Old Navy's lookalike campaign could allegedly harm Sears' Kardashian Kollection campaign, which hadn't yet launched at the time she filed suit. Others speculate that the real reason is because the lookalike model/actress is now dating Kim's ex-boyfriend and football player, Reggie Bush. Either way, it will be interesting to see whether Kim can prevail in her claims for unfair competition under the Lanham Act (15 U.S.C. § 1125-a), and violations of the common law and statutory rights of publicity.
Soon after the Kardashian Kollection debuted at Sears, handbag designer Monica Botiker sent a cease and desist letter to the company, alleging a faux leather handbag from Sears' Kardashian Kollection resembles one of her bags. Sears promptly pulled the Kardashian bag from its website. Given the Kardashian's fiercely protective stance over their brand (which is entirely appropriate and smart), it is interesting to see them on the other side of the fight. If a fashion company wants to be taken seriously when it wields the trademark laws as a sword, it should take care not to unfairly encroach on and have respect for others' rights.