The various LNG Export Terminals proposed to be built in British Columbia may be subject to environmental assessment (or EA) under both the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act, 2012 and the British Columbia Environmental Assessment Act. The EA process, whether under the Federal or Provincial legislation, examines projects to identify adverse environmental, economic, social, heritage and health effects that may occur during development and operation of proposed facilities. The EA process includes involvement/consultation with interested parties such as First Nations and working groups, technical studies and the development of comprehensive reports.

In order to minimize duplication and streamline these generally similar Federal and Provincial processes, the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA) and the British Columbia Environmental Assessment Office (the BC EAO) have entered into a Memorandum of Understanding on the Substitution of Environmental Assessments with the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency  (the MOU). The MOU provides a mechanism for the CEAA to issue a Substitution Order and to effectively substitute the BC EAO’s process for its own and to rely on the record established by the BC EAO in conducting its EA of projects located in BC, such as the LNG Export Terminals. Any such Substitution Order is subject to certain terms and conditions including as to the general nature of the process to be run by the BC EAO and also clearly preserves the right of the Federal government to exercise any judgement or discretion which it may possess under applicable Federal legislation as it sees fit. However the MOU does at least hold out the prospect of reducing unnecessarily duplicative proceedings.

Already, the BC EAO has been substituted for the CEAA in connection with several of the most advanced EA Applications – and many industry participants and commentators believe this trend is likely to continue as further EA Applications are submitted and processed.

The BC EAO EA process consists of three Stages:

  • Pre-Application Stage: no fixed timeline; it will largely be influenced by the time it takes to conduct the necessary field studies and fulfill the Application Information Requirements in order for a project proponent’s EA Application to be accepted as complete by the BC EAO.  
  • Application Review Stage: 180 days following acceptance by the BC EAO of an EA Application for it to deliver an Assessment Report and Recommendation.  
  • Decision Stage: 45 days following delivery of the BC EAO Assessment Report and Recommendation.

The following chart provides a summary of the major BC LNG Export Terminals announced to date and the status of their EA Applications.

Click here to view table.

Notes

  1. Pre-Application Stage:The Pre-Application Stage is used to ensure that EA Applications contain the information necessary for the BC EAO to actually undertake a project EA and make recommendations. The BC EAO issues Application Information Requirements (AIR) which identify the matters that will be considered in the EA and what information must be included in an EA Application. A working group is established and is involved in the development of the AIR. As well, First Nations are consulted. The AIR include baseline studies, project benefits (including socio-economic impacts such as estimated government revenues and contributions to community development), cumulative impacts and proposed mitigation measures and First Nations impacts. Neither the legislation nor the BC EAO impose time restrictions on the Pre-Application Stage, however there is a maximum 30-day limit for the BC EAO to evaluate and determine completeness of  an EA Application.  
  2. Application Review Stage:Following acceptance of an EA Application, the Application Review Stage begins. This involves public comment periods and the drafting by the BC EAO of an Assessment Report to document: (i) the findings of the assessment; (ii) outstanding issues; and (iii) methods to address documented issues. The BC EAO will share its draft Assessment Report with the proponent, the working group and First Nations. The BC EAO typically provides three weeks for comment. As the last step of the Application Review Stage, the BC EAO submits its final Assessment Report, which includes recommendations, to the British Columbia Minister of Environment and the Minister of LNG Development (the Ministers) who have authority to decide whether or not to issue an Environmental Assessment Certificate. The BC EAO has a maximum of 180 days following the acceptance of an EA Application to deliver its Assessment Report.  
  3. Decision Stage:Upon receiving the BC EAO’s Assessment Report, the Ministers have 45 days to make a decision. In doing so, the Ministers must consider the Assessment Report, any documents accompanying it and any other matters they believe are relevant to public interest. If the Ministers issue an Environmental Assessment Certificate, the proposed project may proceed and provincial authorities may issue other necessary project approvals, subject to the satisfaction of approval requirements. If a Federal EA is triggered, the Federal Minister of Environment’s approval is also required, even if a Substitution Order has been issued under the MOU. Similar to the Provincial process, if the Federal Minister issues a positive EA decision, Federal authorities may issue other necessary approvals under their jurisdiction.