New York and Massachusetts are the latest states to introduce tax legislation targeting digital advertising and data collection. Like the similar bills introduced earlier in Connecticut, New York, and Indiana, proposals similar to these latest New York and Massachusetts bills have been rejected by the respective legislatures in prior sessions.
New York revisits the commercial data collection tax
New York legislators continue to introduce bills targeting the digital economy and data collection. On January 18, New York State Senator Liz Krueger (D), Chair of the Senate Finance Committee, introduced S2012, which imposes a monthly excise tax on for-profit entities collecting and selling data from more than one million New Yorkers per month. The tax would apply regardless of how the data is collected, whether by electronic or other means.
The tax rate in S2012 would apply on a graduated scale based on the number of New York consumers whose data the taxpayer collects in a month. The tax starts at 5 cents per individual per month on the number of New York consumers over one million, which would cost businesses at a minimum $50,000.05 per month. The tax rate then gradually increases both in rate plus an additional flat rate amount. The highest rate is 50 cents per month on the number of New York consumers over ten million, plus a flat rate of $2,250,000. This legislation was previously introduced by Sen. Krueger during both the 2021 and 2022 legislative sessions in New York.
Massachusetts throws digital taxes against the wall to see what sticks
Massachusetts legislators have introduced a furry of bills that would tax digital advertising, commercial data collection, or the sale of personal information.On January 18 and 20, state legislators in Massachusetts introduced six draft bills that would adopt a digital advertising services tax. Additional bills were introduced that would tax commercial data collection or the sale of personal information. Those bills are:
- HD 1507 was filed on January 18 and is pending committee referral. The bill draft would establish a special commission to conduct a comprehensive study relative to generating revenue from digital advertising that is displayed inside of Massachusetts by companies that generate over $100 million a year in global revenue.
- HD 1683 was also filed on January 18; this bill draft would assess and levy in each calendar year an excise on the sale of digital advertising services provided within the commonwealth. Revenue from digital advertising services would be required to be remitted monthly. The excise would be assessed at a rate equal to 6.25 percent of the annual gross revenue from digital advertising services provided within the commonwealth. The first $1 million in revenue would be exempt.
- HD 3052 was filed on January 20; the bill would impose a 5 percent tax on persons with revenue from digital advertising services in excess of $25 million per year. The tax would apply to digital advertising services accessed via a digital interface within the state.
- HD 3144 would impose a tiered digital advertising tax with rates of 5, 10, and 15 percent based on annual gross revenues from digital advertising provided in the state, based on IP address of the user’s device on which the advertising is accessed. The tax is imposed on persons with more than $100,000 of digital advertising services in Massachusetts. The draft was filed on January 20.
- HD 3230 would impose a 6.25 percent excise tax on digital advertising services provided in Massachusetts. The service will be deemed to be in the state if the advertising is received on the user’s device with an IP address in the state. The draft was filed on January 20.
- SD 1439 was filed on January 19 and is pending committee referral. The bill would impose a tiered digital advertising tax with rates of 5, 10, and 15 percent based on annual gross revenues from digital advertising provided in the state, based on IP address of the user’s device on which the advertising is accessed. The tax is imposed on persons with more than $100,000 of digital advertising services in Massachusetts.
- SD 1711 would tax on the collection of data by commercial data collectors. Similar to the New York Senator Krueger’s bill, SD 1711 would impose a tax on commercial data collectors that collect, maintain, use, processes, sells, or shares consumer data in support of its business activities. The bill also adopts a tired rate structure where the first $1 million of receipts is exempt, but rates thereafter range from $.05 cents per month of the number of Massachusetts consumers if data is collected from more than 1 million less than 2 million Massachusetts consumers, up to $750,000 per month plus $.30 cents per month on the number of Massachusetts consumers if data is collected from more than 6 million Massachusetts consumers.
- SD 1768 would require persons who sell personal information or exchange personal information for consideration in the state to register with the Department of Revenue, and provide certain detailed information concerning the data and the collection of such data. The bill does not specifically impose a tax, but requires the Department to recommend ways to tax businesses selling personal information to the legislature, “to ensure appropriate compensation to the people of the Commonwealth.”