A judgment on what is thought to be the largest civil case in Guernsey's history was handed down on September 4 2017 by the island's Royal Court. The decision has cleared the management of Carlyle Capital Corporation, a Guernsey investment fund that went into insolvency in the wake of the financial crash in 2008, of liability over its collapse.
The Carlyle Group, Carlyle Investment Management and TCGH successfully defended claims against them, including that their management of a Guernsey fund was in breach of duties alleged to be owed to it that led to total investment losses in the 2008 financial crisis.
Together with the Carlyle Group companies, the Royal Court's judgment also dismissed all claims considered at trial against each of its seven executive and non-executive directors.
The case, which is valued at well over £1 billion, involved a trial that ran just short of six months, and encompassed 971 pages of pleadings, 187 pleaded breaches of duty, 48 days of cross-examination of both fact and expert witnesses and culminated in a 525-page judgment handed down by Lieutenant Bailiff Hazel Marshall, sitting alone. It is understood to be the biggest trial that took place across the commonwealth in 2016.
Funds litigation in Guernsey
The scale of the case underlines Guernsey's position as not only one of the world's largest offshore finance centres, but also a venue capable of handling the most complex and demanding funds litigation cases. Three particular reasons stand out.
First, the technical infrastructure available at the Guernsey Royal Court is of a quality which exceeds expectations for a jurisdiction of this size. Throughout the trial, 4,872 documents were referred to. The technology available allowed the instantaneous downloading of documents so that hard copy documents were rarely needed, increasing the speed at which witnesses could be examined and the ease of locating documentation. A live transcript feed was also available for the judge, all advocates, instructing counsel, onshore counsel and various support staff in the courtroom, as well as a live feed of the hearing which was available to members of the parties in the United States. Further, due to unforeseen circumstances, one expert witness was able to give live video evidence remotely. This shows that the Guernsey Royal Court can deal with large trials which involve a vast amount of documentation, lengthy witness evidence and multiple parties to the action.
The second strength demonstrated by the case is the skill and expertise of the Guernsey bar and judiciary. This large and complex trial could take place in a relatively small jurisdiction due to the breadth, depth and quality of the lawyers acting. The size and strength of the Guernsey bar allows multiple parties, which there often are in litigation involving funds disputes, to be skilfully represented. This, coupled with the expertise of the judiciary, ensures that investors, and any other parties to a funds dispute, have the confidence to invest in funds in Guernsey. Marshall, sitting alone at the trial, is a pre-eminent queen's counsel and former specialist chancery judge and was well-placed to hear this dispute. This therefore gives investors the comfort that if something goes wrong with a fund, any dispute will be fairly and expertly addressed.
Finally, the strength of the island's legislation relating not only to financial services, but also to companies and directors makes Guernsey stand out. Guernsey's comprehensive laws on areas such as director's duties also make the jurisdiction attractive to professionals and practitioners who are involved in the funds industry. For example, a number of the alleged pleaded breaches of duty by the liquidators of Carlyle Capital Corporation involved the duties owed by directors of a Guernsey company. The law on directors' duties in Guernsey is clear, developed and fully recognisable for any professionals and insolvency practitioners familiar with the common law regime.
As shown above, Guernsey is proving to be one of the world's key players in the investment funds industry – in the first quarter of 2017 (the last period for which data is available), the Guernsey Financial Services Commission published statistics showing that the net asset value of total funds under management and administration in Guernsey was £266.5 billion.
These numbers are no accident – it is due to the technical infrastructure available in the island, the skills of practitioners and the quality of its regulation and legislation. In exactly the same way, Carlyle has demonstrated that the same factors – technical infrastructure, skills and the quality of legislation – make the island perfectly equipped to handle the most complex funds litigation cases.
For further information on this topic please contact Simon Davies or Charlotte Henshall at Ogier by telephone (+44 1534 514 000) or email (email@example.com or firstname.lastname@example.org). The Ogier website can be accessed at www.ogier.com.
This article was first published by the International Law Office, a premium online legal update service for major companies and law firms worldwide. Register for a free subscription.