On September 15, 2011, the Commission determined to broadly review most of ALJ Charneski’s findings of violations, no violations, and validity in Inv. No. 337-TA-710, Certain Personal Data and Mobile Communications Devices and Related Software. The complainant is Apple, Inc. of California, et al., and the respondents are HTC Corp. of Taiwan, et al. and Exedia, Inc. of Texas. ALJ Charneski's initial determination found violations of Section 337 as to two of the four patents-in-suit, no violation as to the other two patents, and that all four patents are valid. The Commission determined to review the claim constructions for terms in each of the four patents, as well as the finding of violation for two of the patents, the finding of no violation for two of the patents, the findings on domestic industry for three of the patents, and the findings of validity as to all four patents.