On July 24, 2012, Chief ALJ Bullock issued the public version of his June 20, 2012 initial determination in Investigation No. 337-TA-746, Certain Automated Media Library Devices, finding that there was no violation of section 337. Judge Bullock held that the asserted claims were valid and that a domestic industry exists for one of the two asserted patents, but found that the Respondents do not induce the direct infringement asserted against other Respondents (who were terminated earlier in the investigation based on a settlement agreement) and lacked the requisite knowledge for contributory infringement.