1 Derivatives London Client Alert December 2016 B&M Global Derivatives webinars Click here What Pension Schemes need to know about the latest EMIR rules for margining of non-cleared OTC derivatives The European Commission has published longawaited EMIR rules for margining non-cleared OTC derivatives. Furthermore the European Parliament has indicated no objection to the rules raising the likelihood of an expedited timetable with possible January 2017 start. On 4th October 2016 the European Commission (the Commission) approved and published technical standards1 which set out detailed rules on margin (collateral) that must be exchanged with respect to OTC derivatives not cleared by a central counterparty (the Margin Rules). The Commission's approval of the Margin Rules kick-started a 90 day period2 within which the European Parliament or Council of the EU could object. On 26th October the European Parliament declared that it would raise no objections to the Margin Rules. To date, the Council has not declared its own position, but if, as anticipated, it confirms its non-objection to the Margin Rules this month then they could conceivably be published in the Official Journal of the EU in December and come into force 20 days thereafter. This leads to the possibility of the initial margin mandate taking effect as early as January 2017 for the largest European dealers. This has raised criticism from market participants who fear implementation close to year end could lead to significant market difficulties. Whilst pension scheme arrangements3 entering into OTC derivatives for hedging purposes have been given a deferral from the obligations under EMIR to clear OTC derivatives transactions 1 Regulatory technical standards pursuant to Article 11 European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EU) No 648/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council. 2 Extendable by one further 3 month period although this seems unlikely in this case. 3 See Glossary below for definition of "pension scheme arrangement" For More Information please contact Phung Pham Of Counsel – Structured Finance/Derivatives +44 (0)207 919 1031 email@example.com Dean Bennett Associate – Structured Finance/Derivatives +44 (0)207 919 1294 firstname.lastname@example.org 2 (currently until 16 August 2017 but with a Commission proposal to extended this until 16 August 20184 ), any such OTC derivative transactions may still be subject to the Margin Rules once they come in force. For most pension schemes this will mean that they need to ensure they are compliant with the variation margin requirements by 1 March 20175 . Overview of margin requirements for pensions schemes The Margin Rules set out the requirement for financial counterparties and non-financial counterparties (as both terms are defined in EMIR6 ) who are over the clearing threshold7 (so called NFC+) to exchange initial margin (IM) and variation margin (VM) with their OTC derivatives counterparties with respect to transactions not subject to the clearing obligation. This will mean that pension scheme arrangements which are categorised as an FC or an NFC+ will be required to comply with the many procedures and operational requirements imposed by the Margin Rules such as the requirement to have documentation risk procedures in place covering, amongst other things, collateral eligibility, VM & IM calculations and collection, collateral liquidity verification, regular monitoring and reporting. Such "in-scope" entities8 must, subject to the exemptions and phase-in mentioned below, Calculate and exchange variation margin (VM) on a daily basis Calculate and exchange initial margin (IM) on each trade date, payment date, expiry date and at a minimum every ten business days with no offset being allowed between IM posted and collected Meet strict delivery timing requirements for the collateral, in most cases requiring collateral to be provided within the same business day as the date of the calculation although, subject to certain conditions, VM can be provided within two business 4 The Commission has determined that this should be extended further and a draft regulation is in progress to extend the transitional period to 16 August 2018 see Client Alert Moreover on 29th November in its Report on the EMIR Review the European Commission has concluded that an assessment should be made as to whether the current exemption could be prolonged or made permanent without compromising on EMIR's objective of reducing systemic risk as pension scheme arrangements would still be subject to bilateral margin requirements for OTC transactions that are not centrally cleared that mitigate systemic risks. 5 Assuming OTC derivatives portfolios of less than €3 billion, Article 37 (Transitional Provisions) will bring variation margin requirements into effect on the date that is the later of 1 March 2017 or one month following the date of entry into force of the Margin Rules, making 1st March 2017 the most likely date for application of the Variation Margin requirement to the majority of pension schemes. See Phase-in for VM below 6 See Glossary below for definitions of FC and NFC 7 See Glossary below for definitions of clearing threshold 8 In calculating the positions for the clearing thresholds, an NFC must include all the OTC derivative contracts entered into by the NFC or by other nonfinancial entities within its group, which are not objectively measurable as reducing risks directly relating to the commercial activity or treasury financing activity of the non-financial counterparty or of that group. See also Client Alert Sixteen UK pension schemes receive temporary exemption from EMIR clearing obligation (March 2016) See also Client Alert EMIR Clearing Obligation - Pension Exemption (February 2015) concerning the extension of the transitional period from 16th August 2015 to 16th August 2017 3 days of calculation9 Comply with concentration limits and diversification requirements which set quantitative limits on the amount of assets that can be collected from a counterparty based on asset class, issuer and/or the domicile of the issuer. The latest version of the Margin Rules continue to give pensions schemes that are the most active in the OTC derivatives market (i.e. those where IM exchange with its counterparty would be over €1 billion) a carve-out from certain IM concentration limits on sovereign debt and instead, in such cases (against the opinion of the ESAs10) has allowed pensions schemes merely to have procedures and manage concentration risk of certain assets with a requirement for diversification. Moreover pensions schemes are now permitted to monitor concentration limit compliance on a quarterly basis as opposed to daily basis as previously provided Enter into netting and exchange of collateral documentation with their counterparties which meet certain minimum requirements and conduct legal enforceability assessments Undertake credit quality assessments of collateral collected from its OTC counterparties Some of the impact on pension schemes of these onerous requirements will be reduced by the exemptions and thresholds provided by the Margin Rules. The most relevant to pension schemes are set out below. General Exemptions and Transitional provisions Legacy trades - The requirements to exchange IM and VM will only apply to trades entered into after the date that the Margin Rules comes into force. Whilst EMIR Article 11 requires counterparties to have risk-management procedures that require the timely, accurate and appropriately segregated exchange of collateral with respect to OTC derivative contracts entered into on or after 16 August 2012, the Margin Rules make it clear that trades entered into after EMIR itself came into force but before the Margin Rules are in force can continue to be subject to those existing procedures. Minimum Transfer Amount - The risk management procedures may provide that no collateral is collected where the amount due is less than or equal to €500,000. Counterparties are allowed to agree on separate minimum 9 The emphasis in the Article dealing with the provision of Variation Margin (Article 12) has changed from a requirement to "collect" within the same business day to a requirement for the posting party to "provide" within the same business day. It may be that this subtle change of interpretation signals a move by the Commission to give a more favourable settlement cycle by requiring simply that instructions to move collateral are provided on the same day rather than requiring the collateral to be with the collateral taker on the same business day. However more clarity on this area is required possibly in the form of Q&A responses once the Margin Rules are published. 10 ESAs is the collective term for three European Supervisory Authorities, the European Securities & Markets Authority (ESMA), the European Banking Authority (EBA) and the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) 4 transfer amounts for VM and IM however, the sum of the separate minimum transfer amounts should not exceed €500,000. Note, that once this amount is reached the entire collateral amount must be collected. NFC- exemption - An EU pension scheme which is an FC or NFC+ is allowed to have risk management procedures which provide for no collateral exchange if transacting with either EU or non-EU NFCs below the clearing thresholds (so-called NFC-). So if a pension scheme is an NFC- it can negotiate with its counterparties not to post collateral. Exemptions from Initial Margin The Margin Rules envisage the right for counterparties to agree not to exchange IM in a number of circumstances: IM Threshold - IM collected may be reduced by €50 million (or €10 million if both parties are in the same corporate group) subject to an on-going requirement to monitor whether the threshold is exceeded. Notional Amount Threshold - No IM for new OTC transactions if, measured over a given 3 month period in a calendar year, one of the two counterparties has, or belongs to a group that has, aggregate month-end average notional amount of non-centrally cleared OTC derivatives of less than €8 billion. Foreign exchange contracts - No IM required with respect to physically settled FX forwards, FX swaps and the FX "legs" of cross-currency swaps. (NB these transactions are nonetheless to be included when calculating the aggregate notional amount threshold referred to above). No credit risk - Recital 5 of the Margin RTS clarifies that a counterparty under a non-centrally cleared OTC derivative transaction should be able to choose not to collect IM or VM as long as it is not exposed to any credit risk. The recital gives the example of an option seller that need not collect IM or VM from the option buyer if the premium has been fully paid in advance. Phase-in timetable for Margin Rules VM phase-in - VM requirements will apply in two stages. For those counterparties with more than €3 trillion aggregate average notional of non-centrally cleared OTC derivatives, the start date will be one month after the Margin Rules are in force (possibly mid January 2017). For all other in-scope counterparties, VM requirements will commence from the later of 1 March 2017 or one month following the Margin Rules coming into force. 5 IM phase-in - IM requirements are being phased-in over the period commencing one month after the Margin Rules are in force (possibly mid January 2017) and will be fully applied from 1 September 2020. Initially, the IM requirement will apply where both parties have, or belong to groups each of which has, an aggregate average notional of non-centrally cleared derivatives over €3 trillion. This figure gradually reduces until by 1 September 2020, the threshold for being in-scope of the IM requirements is set at €8 billion. VM Product specific phase-in - Foreign exchange forwards and single stock equity options and index options are subject to additional phase-in periods. No VM is required to be exchanged with respect to o FX forwards Until the earlier of 31 December 2018 and the date MiFID technical standards are in force which will harmonise the definition of FX forwards across the Union. o Single stock equity options and index options Until 3 years from the entry into force of the Margin Rules. Glossary ‘pension scheme arrangement’ means: (a) institutions for occupational retirement provision within the meaning of Article 6(a) of Directive 2003/41/EC, including any authorised entity responsible for managing such an institution and acting on its behalf as referred to in Article 2(1) of that Directive as well as any legal entity set up for the purpose of investment of such institutions, acting solely and exclusively in their interest; (b) occupational retirement provision businesses of institutions referred to in Article 3 of Directive 2003/41/EC; (c) occupational retirement provision businesses of life insurance undertakings covered by Directive 2002/83/EC, provided that all assets and liabilities corresponding to the business are ring-fenced, managed and organised separately from the other activities of the insurance undertaking, without any possibility of transfer; (d) any other authorised and supervised entities, or arrangements, operating on a national basis, provided that: (i) they are recognised under national law; and (ii) their primary purpose is to provide retirement benefits; 6 ‘financial counterparty’ means an investment firm authorised in accordance with Directive 2004/39/EC, a credit institution authorised in accordance with Directive 2006/48/EC, an insurance undertaking authorised in accordance with Directive 73/239/EEC, an assurance undertaking authorised in accordance with Directive 2002/83/EC, a reinsurance undertaking authorised in accordance with Directive 2005/68/EC, a UCITS and, where relevant, its management company, authorised in accordance with Directive 2009/65/EC, an institution for occupational retirement provision within the meaning of Article 6(a) of Directive 2003/41/EC and an alternative investment fund managed by AIFMs authorised or registered in accordance with Directive 2011/61/EU; ‘non financial counterparty’ means an undertaking established in the Union other than a CCP, a financial counterparty, a trading venue or a trade repository. clearing threshold means (a) EUR 1 billion in gross notional value for OTC credit derivative contracts; (b) EUR 1 billion in gross notional value for OTC equity derivative contracts; (c) EUR 3 billion in gross notional value for OTC interest rate derivative contracts; (d) EUR 3 billion in gross notional value for OTC foreign exchange derivative contracts; (e) EUR 3 billion in gross notional value for OTC commodity derivative contracts and other OTC derivative contracts not provided for under points (a) to (d). See Article 11 Regulatory Technical Standards 149/2013 Baker & McKenzie Derivatives Practice - London Baker & McKenzie is one of the world's leading international derivatives practices and we have developed a vast wealth of experience and talent around the world which we harness to provide an unparalleled global service to our clients. Our approach is to provide practical, professional and cost-effective advice. We act for a diverse client base including corporate end-users both multinational and domestic, investment and commercial banks, governmental and supranational entities, insurance companies, financial market intermediaries, funds and investors. Our wide client base gives us a unique view of all aspects of the global derivatives market. We advise on derivatives regulation, clearing and the full range of derivative products from OTC derivatives and exchange traded products to debt capital markets instruments and securitisation structures. 7 Baker & McKenzie International is a Swiss Verein with member law firms around the world. In accordance with the common terminology used in professional service organizations, reference to a "partner" means a person who is a partner, or equivalent, in such a law firm. Similarly, reference to an "office" means an office of any such law firm. This may qualify as "Attorney Advertising" requiring notice in some jurisdictions. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Before you send e-mail to Baker & McKenzie, please be aware that your communications with us through this message will not create a lawyer-client relationship with us. Do not send us any information that you or anyone else considers to be confidential or secret unless we have first agreed to be your lawyers in that matter. Any information you send us before we agree to be your lawyers cannot be protected from disclosure. This Client Alert is for information purposes only. Its contents do not constitute legal advice and should not be regarded as detailed advice in individual cases. For further information, to contact the Team, or to subscribe/unsubscribe to the Client Alert, please email email@example.com.