After seeking comments with a draft on December 7, 2016 (“Draft”), on June 28, 2017, China’s National Development and Reform Commission (“NDRC”) and the Ministry of Commerce (“MOFCOM”) jointly issued the Catalogue for Guidance of Foreign Invested Industries (2017 Amendment) (“2017 Catalogue”, 《外商投资产业指导目录(2017修订)》). The 2017 Catalogue becomes effective on July 28, 2017 and will replace the current 2015 version.

Major developments:

  • In line with the legislative plan, the 2017 Catalogue now officially gives birth to a negative list for foreign investment enterprises (“FIE”) in China.
  • The reform “from approval to filing” in market access control is continued.
  • Compared with the 2015 version, the 2017 Catalogue reduces the restricted/prohibited industries from 93 items to 63 items, while keeping the number of encouraged industries basically unchanged.

Below, we highlight some details under the revised law affecting, among others foreign investment in infrastructure, automotive, medical instruments, chemicals, food and agriculture, as well as some high-end manufacturing, and services like banking, telecoms, logistics, credit rating, cultural and research activities.

1. New structure - “Encouraged + FIE Negative List”

The 2017 Catalogue officially adopts a new structure. It now consists of two parts:

  • a list of all the encouraged industries including those with restrictions, and
  • the Foreign Investment Access Negative List as special access administration measure (colloquially referred to as “FIE Negative List”).

The FIE Negative List comprises of general statements, and further sub-parts listing restricted and prohibited industries for foreign investment in China, plus the special encouraged industries with restrictions on management and/or shareholding ratios.

The birth of the FIE Negative List is one further step to the State Council’s goal of managing market access for both foreign and domestic investors with two negative lists starting from 2018:

  • one master negative list to regulate market access for both domestic and foreign investment in general; and
  • one FIE Negative List (i.e. the 2017 Catalogue for the time being) to additionally regulate aspects affecting solely foreign investment.

This is based on the Opinions of the State Council on Implementing of the System of Negative List for Market Access (《国务院关于实行市场准入负面清单制度的意见》) of December 1, 2015 and other related rules.

2. Changes Proposed by the Draft - All Accepted

The 2017 Catalogue officially accepted all changes proposed by the Draft (please refer to our previous article for details).

Newly Added as “Encouraged”Deleted from “Restricted”
  • New in Infrastructure: construction and operation of city parking facilities.
  • New for Medical Instruments: manufacturing of smart first aid medical equipment; remanufacturing of key components of medical imaging equipment.
  • Less Restricted in Automotive: company form for manufacturing of “automobile electronic network technology” and “components for the input (sensor and sampling systems) and output (actuators) of electronic control systems, EPS electronic controllers” are not limited to joint ventures anymore.
  • Less Restricted for Motorbikes: not limited to two joint ventures within China or share ratios anymore.
  • Less Restricted in Logistics: tallying for foreign vessels and highway passenger transport are not restricted anymore.
  • Less Restricted in Credit Rating: credit checking and rating services are not restricted anymore.

3. Opening up in the High-End Manufacturing Industries

To promote high-end manufacturing, some cutting edge technologies (e.g. VR, AR, 3D printing etc.) have been added beyond the Draft as “encouraged” industries for foreign investment (see below table).

The automobile industry with “clean energy” technology is another winner. For new energy or pure electric cars, the 2017 Catalogue encourages foreign investment in the production of parts, removes the joint venture restrictions for automobile OEMs (note: normal car makers remain subject to share ratio restrictions and the limit of two joint ventures) and also encourages the building of hydrogen refueling stations.

Encouraged Industries - Key Changes in Comparison to the Draft (not exhaustive)

Newly Added as “Encouraged”Deleted from “Restricted”
  • New in VR, AR, 3D Printing: research and development (“R&D”), and manufacturing of virtual reality (VR) equipment, augmented reality (AR) equipment, and key parts of 3D printing equipment.
  • New in Food: R&D and manufacturing of formula food for infants, children, or for special medical use purposes.
  • New in Chemicals: manufacturing of nylon 12, and one raw material for synthetic materials.
  • New in Automotive: manufacturing of seven key parts of new energy automobiles (e.g. air compressors); construction and operation of hydrogen refueling stations.
  • New in Environment: manufacturing of hydrologic monitoring sensors.
  • Less Restricted in Automotive: makers of pure electric cars are not limited to two joint ventures within China anymore.
  • Less Restricted in Agriculture: the construction and operation of large wholesale markets of agricultural products is not restricted anymore.

4. Caution in the Banking, Telecom and Cultural Sectors

The 2017 Catalogue limits the telecom industries to the scope promised under the WTO agreements. Shanghai Free Trade Zone claimed to have exceeded the WTO promises in 2014. One may speculate that less-far reaching position might have resulted from the changed perspective under TPP (Trans-Pacific Partnership)/BIT (Bilateral investment treaties) and possibly a fading interest of China.

The shareholder qualifications in the banking industry are now also specified, enhancing the supervision and regulation of financial institutions.

Restricted Industries - Key Changes in Comparison to the Draft (not exhaustive)

Added as “Restricted” / in the FIE Negative List
  • Limitations for Telecoms: limited to those operations promised to be opened under WTO agreements.
  • Limitations for Banking: for foreign invested banks (including wholly foreign invested banks, joint ventures or branches of foreign banks): the controlling shareholder(s)/investor(s) must be offshore commercial banks; the non-controlling shareholders can be offshore financial institutions.
  • Limitation for news and cultural services: for purpose of providing such services (including Internet related news and cultural services) within China, the service providers outside the territory of China must comply with prevailing rules regarding approvals, security evaluations, rules on senior management etc.

5. The Prohibited Areas

In comparison to the Draft, the 2017 Catalogue tightens control over some news, media, and cultural related industries as well as research institutions of humanity and social sciences.

Prohibited Industries - Key Changes in Comparison to the Draft (not exhaustive)

Added into the Prohibited / FIE Negative List
  • Prohibited Publications: editing of certain publications (e.g. books, newspapers, electric publications remains closed to foreign investors).
  • Prohibited Radio/TV/Video Services: providing Radio/TV/Video services on demand; installing ground facilities to receive satellite TV/radio programs; and the import of radio/TV programs all remain closed.
  • Prohibited News: prohibited news institutions are now defined as “including but not limited to news agencies”; also not allowed for foreign investment are Internet news information services, information publishing/publication service via the Internet.
  • Prohibited Research Institutions: investment into research institutions of humanity and social sciences remains closed.

The changes reflect the aim to safeguarding and further developing certain ideology. It follows the call of the Communist Party of China for the “three self-confidents” in 2012 when President Xi was elected as the Party leader.