Rosenthal Collins Group, LLC v. Trading Techs. Int'l., Inc., No. 05 C 4088, Slip Op. (N.D. Ill. June 1, 2011) (Coleman, J.).
Judge Coleman denied plaintiff Rosenthal Collins Group's ("RCG") motion to reconsider or clarify the Court's February 23, 2011 Order entering defendants judgment in favor of declaratory judgment defendant Trading Technologies ("TT") and sanctioning RCG $1 million. While the discovery misconduct - which the Court described as "attempted fraud" - related to invalidity, it was appropriate to enter default judgment as to infringement because TT's infringement case would have been "futile" if the "fabricated" evidence had been successfully used to invalidate the patents. Furthermore, RCG should not be allowed to benefit from the thwarting of its misconduct. Finally, the Court's sanctions were not criminal, they were made pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 37 and the Court's inherent powers.