Today, the Court of Appeal for Ontario fined Metron Construction Corporation $750,000 for the Criminal Code offence of criminal negligence causing death. The penalty was issued as part of a detailed decision allowing a Crown appeal of the fine of $200,000 originally imposed on Metron following its July 13, 2012, guilty plea to the criminal charge issued after five workers were injured, four fatally, after falling thirteen storeys on December 24, 2009. In granting the appeal, the Court of Appeal found that the sentencing court erred in the application of sentencing principles and imposed a fine that was manifestly unfit.
There are many notable findings and comments in the decision including:
- The Court of Appeal’s endorsement that corporate criminal liability can be based solely on the actions of a supervisor (for more on this point, please see our September 2012 Management Update);
- A conviction for criminal negligence causing death is distinguishable from a regulatory health and safety conviction and the sentence imposed must reflect that difference;
- A corporation cannot distance itself from the conduct of a supervisor based on the supervisor’s rank in the corporate hierarchy or level of managerial responsibility; and
- Sentencing courts can impose sentences that threaten the viability of corporations.
Metron is the first corporation in Ontario to be convicted under the criminal negligence provisions of the Criminal Code, as amended by Bill C-45 in 2004, involving workplace health and safety. The fine imposed by the Court of Appeal is the largest fine ever imposed on a corporation for criminal negligence relating to a health and safety violation and the decision is the first detailed analysis from an appellate court on the sentencing factors applicable to corporations under the Criminal Code. A more fulsome analysis of the decision and its potential impact will follow shortly in our OHS & Worker’s Compensation Management Update. However, many of the issues considered by the Court of Appeal were set out in our July 13, 2012, Management Update which readers may wish review.