New York City has appealed a trial court decision overturning a determination that expanded polystyrene foam (EPS) cannot be recycled, which had resulted in a municipal ban on the material. In re Restaurant Action Alliance, NYC, No. 100734 (N.Y. App. Ct., filed October 26, 2015).
The appeal argues that the commissioner of the Department of Sanitation of New York conducted an extensive review over six months before reaching the determination that EPS could not feasibly be recycled and, thus, should be banned from commercial use within the city. “City Council prudently left determination of predictive questions about the future feasibility and sustainability of recycling foam waste to the judgement of the Commissioner,” the appeal argues. “[The trial court] was wrong to second guess the Commissioner’s determination based primarily on a short-term recycling plan proposed by the world’s largest foam manufacturer.” Additional information about the lower court’s ruling appears in Issue 579 of this Update