Back in 2012, we published an article forewarning about the proposed changes to the Estate Administration Tax Act in Bill 173 (Better Tomorrow for Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2011). After much discussion and attempts by various organizations to obtain amendments to the proposed changes, the regulations giving effect to Bill 173 came into force on January 1, 2015 and the changes are as onerous as promised.
As a refresher on the estates administration process in Ontario, when a person dies, the individual(s) appointed to manage the deceased’s assets are known as the estate trustee(s). However, some assets may not be accessible to the estate trustee until he, she or it provides evidence of their appointment. In these cases, the estate trustee must apply for a Certificate of Appointment of Estate Trustee (“Certificate of Appointment”) from the Ontario Superior Court of Justice and pay an estate administration tax on the value of the assets of the deceased’s estate.
Changes Effective January 1, 2015
Any application submitted on or after January 1, 2015 will be subject to the new regulation. A new information return must now be received by the Ministry of Finance within 90 days of issuance of the Certificate of Appointment. The form of the return and its contents are prescribed by regulation. One of the items an estate trustee must now provide to the Minister of Finance is a breakdown of the fair market value of each asset owned by the deceased on the date of death as well as a detailed description of the asset. This will require valuations and appraisals of certain assets and the collection and recording of more information, which will be a much more onerous process.
Records and documentation of each asset are a crucial part of the administration. If the estate trustee becomes aware that any information submitted in the estate information return is incorrect or incomplete or subsequently discovers another asset, a revised return must be filed no later than 30 days after the estate trustee becomes aware of this information.
There is also no mechanism in place for ending the ongoing liability of an estate trustee once the estate is ready to be wound up. The Ministry has four years from the date of the return to assess. The Ministry briefly considered the idea of providing a Clearance Certificate to estate trustees but this proposal did not materialize in the regulation.
Failure to comply with the regulation could result in a fine of not less than $1,000 and up to twice the amount of tax payable by the estate, imprisonment for up to two years or both.
What Happens Now?
The additional work and potential liability may result in an increased reluctance to act as an estate
trustee. On that note, greater consideration should be given as to who would be appropriate to appoint as
estate trustee now that the task of administering an estate has become more complicated.
Testators may also want to consider arranging their estate plans so as to minimize the need for a
Certificate of Appointment. Estate planning strategies that were once considered unsuitable for relatively
uncomplicated estates are now under re-consideration as a result of the new regime.