Use the Lexology Navigator tool to compare the answers in this article with those from other jurisdictions.

Position of creditors

Forms of security

What are the main forms of security over moveable and immoveable property and how are they given legal effect?

In all provinces except Quebec, the most typical form of security over personal property is a general security agreement which is given legal effect by execution by the parties. Each provincial statute has rules governing how a security interest may attach to personal property. Perfection of a personal property security interest is governed by provincial statute, but typically takes the form of registration or possession. 

The most typical form of security or immovable property is a mortgage, which must be in writing and registered against title to real property. Each province has a statue governing the validity and enforceability of mortgages registered in its jurisdiction.

The regime in the civil law jurisdiction of Quebec is distinct from the other common law provinces. A hypothec (moveable for personal property and immoveable for real property) is the most typical form of security taken. The personal property provisions in Quebec are set out in the Quebec Civil Code. Similar to the Ontario Personal Property Security Act, the Quebec Civil Code requires security interests in personal property to be registered in Quebec’s registry system. Unlike the Ontario Personal Property Security Act, the Quebec Civil Code permits a security interest to be taken in both tangible and intangible property. An immoveable hypothec is registered on title to real property.

Ranking of creditors

How are creditors’ claims ranked in insolvency proceedings?

In general, claims in an insolvency proceeding are ranked as follows:

  • Secured claims – these are established under the Ontario Personal Property Security Act or the Quebec Civil Code and are ranked according to the legislative scheme under which they are devised.
  • Preferred claims – these include employee wage arrears and landlord claims for accelerated rent. Preferred claims are ranked in a prescribed order under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act.
  • Unsecured claims – these are ranked pari passu with each other.

There are also certain priority claims that rank ahead of all creditors. These claims are typically created through statutory priority or by way of a court-ordered super priority charge. 

Can this ranking be amended in any way?

Yes – a court may reorder claims by way of a court order on notice to all creditors.

Click here to view the full article.