Following its consultation in 2015, the Government has now confirmed the changes which will be made in how termination payments will be taxed, and published draft legislation for comment.

The changes will apply “from April 2018″. It is not clear at this stage whether payments pursuant to settlement agreements entered into before that time will be grandfathered under the existing legislation, but that may well be the case.

Key points are:

  • the existing £30,000 income tax exemption for termination payments will continue to apply, as will the unlimited exemption for employee national insurance contributions (“NICs”) (provided, as now, the payment is not “earnings”). However, employers’ NICs will be due on any termination payment in excess of £30,000, making termination payments more costly for employers;
  • all PILONs will now be taxed (irrespective of whether they are contractual or non-contractual). In fact, any payment or benefit which the employee would have received during his notice period (had he worked it) will be subject to tax and NICs Further details of how this provision will operate in practice are set out below;
  • the exemption for payments due to injury and disability will be retained, but will be amended so that it will not extend to injury to feelings unless the injury amounts to a “psychiatric injury or other recognised medical condition”;
  • foreign service relief will be withdrawn. This may raise some interesting questions, for example, about whether a payment to an employee who has worked outside the UK for several years but for a UK employer, will be caught;
  • the other existing exemptions will remain, including payments made to tax exempt or registered pension schemes, and in respect of legal costs.

PILONs, contractual and non-contractual payments

The intention is that any payment which an employee would have been entitled to receive had they worked their notice period will be subject to tax and NICs and fall outside the £30,000 exemption. Any other (non-contractual) termination payments will continue to benefit from the £30,000 exemption.

The draft legislation works as follows:

  • the employer must calculate the aggregate amount the employee would have been entitled to had he worked for the remainder of his notice period (“PB”). PB is calculated by aggregating the following sums:

(i) “P”: this is essentially the amount of general earnings which would have been earned by the employee during that part of the “minimum notice” period which is not actually worked, calculated by reference to the employee’s earnings for the 12 weeks prior to the end of employment (where no notice to terminate is given) or prior to the giving of notice (where notice is given). If the full minimum notice period is worked, this number will be zero. The “minimum notice period” is the minimum notice required to terminate the employee’s employment in accordance with law and his contractual terms. Anti-avoidance provisions will apply to prevent artificial reduction of earnings during the 12 week testing period; and

(ii) “B”: this is the amount of any bonus, commission, incentive “and anything similar” that the employee could reasonably be expected to receive before the end of the employment (including during the minimum notice period) and which is not received before the employment ends;

  • if PB exceeds the amount of the termination payment (excluding any payment by way of compensation for unfair dismissal or redundancy), the full termination payment will be taxable. If PB is less than the amount of the termination payment (after the same exclusions), the amount of PB is taxable, but the excess will attract the £30,000 exemption.

Examples

Employee A:

Employee A is made redundant after 15 years’ service. A is required to work the minimum statutory notice period of 12 weeks. A’s gross salary is £28,000 per year and A is entitled to a statutory redundancy payment of £8,400.

During the notice period, A continues to receive salary. This amounts to £6,450 over the 12 week period. This will be subject to tax and NICs as earnings.

When the employment is terminated at the end of the 12 week notice period A receives a total termination package of £17,400 under a settlement agreement, including the statutory redundancy pay.

Tax treatment: Employee A has worked his entire notice period and is receiving a termination payment that is non-contractual. The full payment benefits from the £30,000 exemption and so no tax or NICs arises.

Employee B:

Employee B resigns giving 6 months’ notice as required by his contract of employment. His gross salary is £80,000 per year. He earns commission of (typically) £1,200 per month and receives a car allowance of £800 per month.

He works 8 weeks of his notice period whilst negotiating a settlement agreement with his employer and is paid £12,308 gross salary (8 weeks’ pay), £2,400 commission and £1,600 car allowance.

The employer makes a payment in lieu of notice of £27,692 (which is the amount of salary he would have received had he worked the balance of his notice period) and an ex gratia payment of £25,000. In accordance with the terms of his employment contract, the other benefits which Employee B receives in addition to salary are not taken into account for the purposes of calculating the PILON. The full termination payment is therefore £52,692.

Tax treatment: Employee B has not worked his full notice period. Had he continued in employment for the full notice period, he would have received £35,692 (i.e. salary of £27,692 (which is “P” on the “PB” formula), commission of £4,800 and car allowance of £3,200 (which together are “B” in the “PB” formula)). Accordingly, £35,692 of the termination payment is subject to tax and NICs. The balance of the termination payment (being £17,000) falls within the £30,000 exemption. This contrasts with the current law under which the employee would have expected to receive (at least) the full ex gratia payment of £25,000 without tax deductions.